Skip to main content
disabilityX

Content Warning

Contains discussion of intimate partner violence, homicide, and the disposal of a body.

safeguardingcommunication barriersservice gapsdomestic violencemental health support

A Silent Scream: Unpacking Systemic Failures in Maryam's Death

Based on Victorian Coroner's FindingAI-Assisted Summary

The coroner's findings into Maryam Hamka's death reveal a tragic intersection of intimate partner violence and potential gaps in support for individuals with acquired brain injury and mental health challenges. This story explores the systemic failures that contributed to her death and highlights the urgent need for improved safety nets.

Story Narration
Pre-recorded
AI Voice

Transcript

Hello, and thank you for joining me. Today, I want to share a story with you... the story of Maryam Hamka. It's a difficult story, one that echoes a devastating reality for far too many, and I want to acknowledge upfront that it contains challenging themes, including intimate partner violence, homicide, and the disposal of a body. Please take care as you listen. Maryam was a real person... a daughter, a sister, a friend. Her brother described her as someone with a "big heart," someone who worried about others before herself. At 36 years old, Maryam had already shown incredible resilience in her life. She had worked as a cleaner, a testament to her dedication and work ethic, and she navigated the world while living with an acquired brain injury and mental health challenges. She had hopes, dreams, and people who loved her deeply. Maryam was not just a name in a report; she was a human being whose life mattered. Tragically, Maryam's life was cut short on April 11, 2021, a victim of intimate partner violence. Her death, and the subsequent discovery of her body, brought to light a horrifying intersection of vulnerabilities and a series of systemic failures that demand our urgent attention and reflection. The coroner's findings into Maryam’s death have laid bare a number of critical gaps in the systems that should have protected her. First, we see a profound failure in providing tailored and integrated support for individuals with complex needs. Maryam lived with an acquired brain injury and mental health challenges, and she was also grappling with substance use. These factors can significantly impact a person's ability to assess danger, navigate complex situations, or even effectively communicate their fears. The system often operates in silos, addressing one issue without fully understanding how it intersects with others. For Maryam, this meant that her unique vulnerabilities, particularly her ABI, might have made it incredibly difficult for her to access, understand, or respond to traditional support mechanisms for intimate partner violence. We need systems that see the whole person, not just a collection of symptoms or labels. Secondly, Maryam’s story highlights a critical failure in recognizing and responding to escalating intimate partner violence, especially when vulnerabilities are present. The details reveal a chilling pattern of harassment, threats, and control from her partner in the days leading up to her death. Maryam confided in friends about her fear, describing herself as "very scared." These were clear warning signs. While we don't know if these specific fears were reported to formal services, the system, as a whole, often struggles to connect these dots, to intervene proactively, or to provide safe, accessible pathways for help. When someone like Maryam, with an acquired brain injury or mental health challenges, expresses fear, those concerns must be amplified and met with a heightened, specialized response. We need communities and services that are equipped to not only hear these cries for help but to act decisively and compassionately. And thirdly, there appears to be a systemic lack of effective communication and collaboration across different support sectors. Maryam's circumstances involved multiple layers of vulnerability – her disabilities, mental health, substance use, and the escalating domestic violence. Often, individuals with such complex needs interact with various services – health, mental health, disability support, housing, and domestic violence agencies. Yet, these services frequently operate independently, leading to fragmented care and critical information not being shared. This means that no single entity holds a complete picture of a person's risk, leaving individuals like Maryam to fall through the cracks. We desperately need integrated care models where information is shared ethically and effectively, ensuring that all professionals involved are aware of the full scope of a person's challenges and risks, and can coordinate a truly holistic safety net. Maryam Hamka’s story matters because it is a stark reminder of the profound cost of these systemic failures. Her death was preventable. It underscores the urgent need for us to do better, to build stronger, more compassionate, and more integrated safety nets for everyone, especially for individuals with disabilities who face additional barriers and vulnerabilities. We must learn from Maryam’s tragic experience to ensure that no other life is lost due to preventable oversights. We must advocate for systems that truly see, hear, and protect every person, regardless of their challenges. Thank you for listening.

Narrated by Axel's AI avatar

A Silent Scream: Unpacking Systemic Failures in Maryam's Death

Maryam’s story is one that echoes a devastating reality for many: the profound vulnerability that can exist when intimate partner violence intersects with complex personal circumstances. The recent coroner's findings into her death, which occurred on April 11, 2021, at the age of 36, lay bare a series of systemic failures that demand our urgent attention. This is not a story about blame, but about learning, about ensuring that no other individual faces such a tragic end due to preventable oversights.

The Life and Loss of Maryam

Maryam was described by her brother as having a "big heart," someone who worried about others before herself. She had previously worked as a cleaner, a testament to her dedication and work ethic. At the time of her death, Maryam was unemployed, as was her partner, Toby Loughnane. The coroner's report notes that both were using illicit substances. Crucially, the report also identifies Maryam as having an acquired brain injury (ABI) and mental health challenges, factors that may have impacted her ability to access support and navigate dangerous situations.

A Trail of Violence and Fear

The events leading up to Maryam's death paint a chilling picture of escalating fear and control. The coroner's findings detail a pattern of behaviour by Mr. Loughnane that included repeated harassment and threats towards Maryam. Even in the days before her death, Maryam confided in friends about her fear of Mr. Loughnane, noting that he had followed her previously. Her distress was palpable; she was described as "very scared and couldn’t sit still" by one friend.

On the evening of April 7, 2021, Mr. Loughnane repeatedly called and messaged Maryam, demanding to know who she was with. He even initiated a FaceTime call to confront her about her companion, forcing Maryam to show her friend on screen. The following evening, Maryam visited another friend, visibly distressed and afraid that Mr. Loughnane knew her whereabouts.

In the early hours of April 9, 2021, Mr. Loughnane sent Maryam numerous harassing and threatening text messages, claiming he was nearby and believing she was cheating on him. On April 10, Maryam was last seen by her mother putting groceries into a van driven by Mr. Loughnane, who then took her to his apartment in Brighton. CCTV footage confirmed their arrival.

The Final Hours: A Descent into Tragedy

Later that evening, Maryam's friend, Shane Allan, called her twice. He recalled Maryam sounding "out of it." A text message sent from Maryam's phone later that night, "Betting;I taxi;soon [sic]" (believed to mean 'Getting in a taxi soon'), was particularly concerning to Mr. Allan, who was unsure if Maryam had sent it. This doubt is echoed by police allegations that Mr. Loughnane sent this message.

The last known evidence of Maryam alive was a video recorded by Mr. Loughnane at 11:45 pm on April 10, 2021. In the video, Maryam appeared distressed and drug-affected, while Mr. Loughnane mocked her. This was followed by neighbours hearing "female screaming and yelling," "significant yelling, banging and screaming" from Mr. Loughnane's apartment between 1:00 am and 3:00 am on April 11, 2021.

It was during this period that Mr. Loughnane killed Maryam. A jury later found him guilty of her murder, rejecting his defence that she died from a drug overdose. The coroner's findings note that Maryam lost a significant amount of blood during this time.

The Cover-Up and Discovery

Following Maryam's death, Mr. Loughnane engaged in a disturbing effort to conceal his actions. He removed Maryam's SIM card from her phone and placed it in his own, later switching them back. He then contacted an associate, Oscar Newman, who arrived at the apartment to find blood on the carpet, drug paraphernalia, and Maryam unresponsive in the shower. Mr. Loughnane was found unconscious in the bedroom, claiming Maryam had overdosed. When Mr. Newman suggested calling an ambulance, Mr. Loughnane refused, stating, "I can't, I'll get done for manslaughter."

Over the following days, Mr. Loughnane purchased cleaning supplies and arranged for a steam cleaner. He then moved Maryam's body to Mr. Newman's car and drove it to Cape Schanck, where he buried her in a shallow grave. He continued to send messages from Maryam's phone, pretending she was still alive.

When Maryam's family contacted police for a welfare check, Mr. Loughnane was uncooperative and nervous. A subsequent search of his apartment revealed evidence of a significant cleaning effort, including towels and sheets soaking in the bathtub and a wet, soapy carpet.

Systemic Failures Identified

The coroner's findings, while not assigning blame for Maryam's death directly to systemic failures, highlight critical areas where support and intervention may have been insufficient:

  • Inadequate Safeguarding for Individuals with ABI and Mental Health Challenges: The report notes Maryam's ABI and mental health challenges. While not explicitly stated as a direct cause, these factors can increase vulnerability, potentially impacting an individual's ability to recognise danger, seek help, or access support services effectively. There appears to have been a lack of robust safeguarding measures that specifically addressed these vulnerabilities in the context of intimate partner violence.
  • Insufficient Response to Family Violence Intervention Orders (FVIOs): While an FVIO was unserved on Mr. Loughnane, its presence suggests a history of reported family violence. The effectiveness of FVIOs relies on timely enforcement and comprehensive support for the person they are intended to protect. The delay in serving the order, and the subsequent events, raise questions about the efficacy of the system in preventing harm.
  • Gaps in Communication and Information Sharing: The messages exchanged between Mr. Loughnane and Maryam, and the suspicious texts sent from Maryam's phone, indicate potential manipulation and deception. The inability of friends to definitively ascertain if Maryam was the one sending messages highlights a potential gap in how individuals in abusive relationships can communicate their distress or seek help, especially if their communication devices are compromised.
  • Limited Support for Victims of Intimate Partner Violence: Maryam's fear and distress were evident to her friends. However, the narrative suggests a lack of readily available, accessible, and immediate support that could have intervened before the situation escalated to such a fatal conclusion.
  • Challenges in Identifying and Addressing Substance Use in the Context of Violence: The report mentions both Maryam and Mr. Loughnane were using illicit substances. While the jury rejected the overdose defence, the interplay between substance use and domestic violence can create complex challenges for both victims and interveners. Services need to be equipped to address these co-occurring issues.

What Could Have Been Done Differently?

For Maryam:

  • Earlier and More Robust Intervention: Had there been earlier and more effective intervention from support services or law enforcement in response to the escalating threats and controlling behaviour, Maryam's life might have been saved.
  • Accessible Support Networks: Greater accessibility to crisis accommodation, counselling, and legal support tailored to individuals with ABI and mental health challenges would have provided Maryam with more options and resources to escape a dangerous situation.

For the System:

  • Proactive Risk Assessment and Intervention: A more proactive approach to risk assessment, particularly when there is a known history of family violence and individuals with identified vulnerabilities, is crucial. This includes ensuring FVIOs are served promptly and effectively.
  • Integrated Support Services: A more integrated approach to support services that addresses both domestic violence and the specific needs of individuals with ABI and mental health challenges is essential. This means better collaboration between domestic violence services, mental health providers, disability support organisations, and law enforcement.
  • Enhanced Communication Safeguards: Exploring technological solutions or protocols that can help individuals in abusive relationships communicate their distress safely, even when their primary communication devices may be monitored or controlled.
  • Training and Awareness: Continued training for frontline workers, police, and healthcare professionals on identifying the signs of coercive control and intimate partner violence, especially in the context of disability and mental health, is paramount.

What This Means for the Disability Community

Maryam's story serves as a stark reminder that individuals with disabilities, including those with ABI and mental health challenges, are disproportionately vulnerable to experiencing domestic and family violence. The systemic failures highlighted in this report are not isolated incidents; they represent broader challenges within our society.

It underscores the critical need for:

  • Disability-Informed Domestic Violence Services: Services that understand the unique barriers and vulnerabilities faced by people with disabilities experiencing violence. This includes accessible communication, trauma-informed approaches, and support tailored to individual needs.
  • Strengthened Safeguarding Frameworks: Robust safeguarding protocols within disability support services that actively identify and respond to risks of domestic violence.
  • Empowerment and Agency: Ensuring individuals with disabilities have the agency and resources to make informed decisions about their safety and to access support without fear of judgment or discrimination.
  • Advocacy and Awareness: Continued advocacy from within the disability community and by allies to raise awareness of these issues and to push for systemic change.

Call to Action

Maryam's life was tragically cut short. Her story compels us to act. We must demand better from our systems, our services, and ourselves.

For individuals with disabilities and their families:

  • Know your rights and available support: Familiarise yourselves with domestic violence support services, disability advocacy organisations, and legal aid in your area.
  • Develop a safety plan: If you are experiencing or fear domestic violence, create a safety plan. This can include having important documents, a change of clothes, and emergency contacts ready.
  • Reach out: Talk to a trusted friend, family member, support worker, or call a domestic violence hotline. You are not alone.
For advocates and service providers:

  • Prioritise integrated service delivery: Foster collaboration and information sharing between domestic violence services, disability support providers, and mental health services.
  • Champion accessible and inclusive practices: Ensure all services are physically, communicatively, and culturally accessible to people with disabilities.
  • Lobby for policy change: Advocate for legislation and policies that strengthen protections for vulnerable individuals and increase funding for essential support services.

Maryam's voice may have been silenced, but her story can ignite a movement for change. Let us honour her memory by working tirelessly to ensure that no one else has to suffer in silence, unheard and unprotected.

Resources:

  • 1800RESPECT: 1800 737 732 - National counselling and support service for domestic, family and sexual violence.
  • Disability Advocacy Network Australia (DANA): https://disabilityadvocacy.org.au/
  • Mental Health Support: Contact your local mental health services or Lifeline Australia at 13 11 14.

Source: Original Document (opens in new tab) (COR 2023 003537)

Related to:

acquired brain injurymental health challenges

Topics:

domestic-violencehomicidecoroner's-inquestsafeguardingdisability-rightsmental-healthABIsupport-servicessystemic-failurevulnerability

Have Your Own Story?

Share your experience with the disability system. We support anonymous publishing.